I Am So Popular: Break Up Camp For Big Girls
Austin Woman’s Club, "Historic Downtown Austin Assets" Among Preservation Texas' Most Endangered Places 2010
Giveaway: Justin Townes Earle @ Stubb's
![_Heat Things Up With <em>Desire</em> at the Blanton [Art Preview]](http://austinist.com/assets_c/2010/02/minter-thumb-110x110-478584.jpg)
Heat Things Up With Desire at the Blanton [Art Preview]
Excellent Show Alert: Bowerbirds & Julie Doiron at Mohawk
Last week, sometime during the night, a 23-inch pecan tree (#NT033) snapped off about five feet above ground and fell near the stone pillars above the pool's parking lot. No one was hurt.
The fallen tree was originally scheduled to be removed, but the determination was later changed (see "Tree Maintenance Table", June 18th) as a result of the public meetings to: "PARD will prune to eliminate dead wood and broken limbs." When called for a comment, Don Gardner, an independent arborist who evaluated some of the trees around Barton Springs, said, "I did not inspect that tree as part of my evaluation. I do remember glancing at the tree during my walk and thinking it should be removed." According to Victor Ovalle, PARD spokesman, the failure has not been analyzed.
Three trees have been cut down around the playground area, but the trimming of dead wood in the trees to be preserved has not yet begun.
add to stumble upon
add to reddit
tweet this
post to facebook
So, wait, he didn't look at this tree? It was on the list to be looked at, but he didn't look at it. Sounds like he was negligent in his job. What other tree did he miss?
This tree was not on the Davey Group list to be evaluated nor on Don Gardner's list. Don Gardner was hired by Save Our Springs to provide a second opinion on the 29 trees identified by Davey for removal.
reading comprehension for the win
I feel like I am reading the Statesman, only 2 days ago
Fair comment. I plead guilty.
Although the photo was from Friday, I only received a call back from Don on Monday. Also, I wanted to attend a PARD meeting this morning on short-term park improvements and ask some further questions. The information I received from PARD last week was, well, incomplete.
also, a huge branch fell a few weeks ago at the pool. it happened early in the day, so thankfully no one was sitting under it. it's sad these trees were not taken care of properly in the first place.
All trees have a life expectancy and eventually die, naturally or otherwise. In ideal conditions, Pecan trees have up to a 300 year life expectancy. It is safe to assume that the Barton Springs area is not considered an ideal condition. The death of these trees has likely been expedited due to the less than ideal growing conditions, soil compaction and disturbance within the tree's critical root zone or from a variety of other causes.
What is lost in the battle of the Barton Springs Pecan trees is the fact that very few trees (any?) have been planted (understory or otherwise) to supplement the "urban forest".
We shouldn't be happy that the City hired a tree removal company to identify trees to be removed. We shouldn't expect healthy looking trees to be an imminent danger to park users. But we should expect the City and Parks Department to realize that regular supplemental tree plantings - in addition to pruning and maintenance - can help offset the natural loss, selective removal or unexpected damage that impact the trees that are so greatly revered.