The Trees at Barton Springs: An Independent Assessment

Wednesday afternoon, under a Barton Springs pecan tree wrapped in a pink ribbon, about 50 people gathered for a tree walk sponsored by Save Our Springs (SOS). They came to inspect some of the 28 trees selected for removal and listen to Don Gardner, an arborist retained by SOS to write an independent report. “Once you start looking at a whole bunch of trees,” Gardner told the crowd, “guess what folks, you’re going to find some that should just not be standing any longer.”


Gardner did not agree with all the recommendations, but he praised Austin’s Urban Forestry Program Manager, Walter Passmore, for performing the first comprehensive inspection in one of the region’s most beloved areas. Gardner then delivered the good news/bad news: “My list says 4-6 trees pretty soon, right away, yesterday, and 5 or 6 others that may have to be taken down once we’ve done some more investigating.

As the group moved from tree to tree, it became clear that there are many structures, sidewalks and retaining walls that have built right next to trees over the years. A black ash on the list of 28, called “a fine specimen” by Gardner, rises out of the Zilker theater stage floor. He thought the tree could be saved. Gardner pointed out the damaged pecan tree (#7) growing in the middle of the playground. Its shade makes summer bearable. Both the Davey Resource Group (DRG) report and Passmore recommended removal due to past damage and poor soil conditions (added clay) that restricted root development. Gardner loves the tree, acknowledged the real safety concerns and wants to perform some additional soundings. It is on his tentative list. For now, the play ground is roped off.

Tree experts can disagree, even with themselves. A great old pecan tree on the pool’s south side (#50) has root decay. In his report, Gardner concurred and recommended removal. The tree’s shade attracts a large crowd in the summer. After some additional looks, he told the group Wednesday that he was less certain and wanted to perform additional root crown excavation. Prompted by a question about costs, Gardner said he preferred to focus on the trees and not the politics. “Let’s save them, let’s work on them, let’s take better care of them,” he extolled. In the end, hard calls between saving or removing and replanting will have to be made.

Save Our Springs is holding a press conference Saturday, May 16, at 9:45 a.m. to show their support for a careful review. The press conference will be held just outside the entrance to the pool.

One word of caution: not every tree encircled with pink tape may be slated for removal. During the walk, someone noticed that tree #14, a pecan next to the main building, had a pink ribbon. It is not on the list. The DRG report is confusing, has errors, and is being revised.

Email This Entry


Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

About Austinist

Austinist is a news and culture website about Austin, Texas. We publish Monday through Friday, and also maintain a guide to local arts and entertainment events that we call the Weekly IST List.

Editor: Allen Y Chen
Publisher: Gothamist

Recent Comments

Dig It

Contribute

Latest Tip:

where's the public outcry over the condition of waterloo park?
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Austinist.

All Our RSS