Synecdoche, New York, Charlie Kaufman's Hamlet:

Charlie Kaufman is an unusual dude. Little to nothing is known about his life, he is intensely private, a man who's reportedly married and has a kid, but even the internet doesn't know the names of his wife or child (to any degree of certainty). Something that's recently been debunked, however, is that Kaufman is a depressed, aloof loner — an idiot-savant incapable of human interaction. In this respect, he has been continually typecast, often by his own writing, which critics imagine emanates from all points in his personal life, days and thoughts.

Fact: Too much has been made about Kaufman's persona and that of his characters. Aside from being a genius, Kaufman is also clever enough in an everyday sense to write outside his life. Not every element of his films is a literal representation of his person. He is there, there is no doubt. But he does not have a twin brother.

Fact: He went to film school at NYU. He interacts with human beings. His Q&A at the Austin Film Festival was as perfectly reasonable, something you might expect from an actual human being. It also gave us as much insight into his thinking as we could have hoped for. It's not that Kaufman's a mystic writing on the mount, he's just more honest about his insecurities. He does not qualify as a Salinger-like recluse.

Synecdoche is Kaufman's directorial debut, and he proves himself more than capable of both directing actors and managing the material. That material, however, proves a little beyond the scope of a single viewing. Just as Shakespeare used Hamlet to expound and reflect on the writer's thoughts about the theater, Kaufman takes the bard's "all the world's a stage," plays with it, makes a souffle, then throws it in a blender.

Appropriately (for something blended), after the halfway point, you will find yourself reaching desperately for some sense of what, in this film, is "fact." It's frustrating when you get lost in its layers.

So we like to treat it as a puzzle. And although it's not as lean and as clever as his other works (Spike Jonze clearly helps him here), or as flat-out suspenseful as, say, Adaptation, someone gave Kaufman the keys to the studio, and it's fun to watch him play.

Here is some background knowledge we'd like to offer up, based on a few weeks' worth of research and observation (and two viewings). *Possible spoiler alert: We're pretty sure that the movie is more enjoyable knowing these things in advance, but if you'd rather feel very virginal and completely in the dark about the whole thing, please skip until the next asterisk.

1)From the press release: "The movie is not a dream." We wish to add that the movie certainly contains dreams, followed by strange, funny abstractions and metaphors (like the infamous burning house), but aside form metaphorical meaning, the arc of the story does exist in the film's "reality."

2)For a definition of "synecdoche" [sin-eck-doe-kee], see our preview, here.

3)Cotard's Syndrome: "is a rare neuropsychiatric disorder in which a person holds a delusional belief that he or she is dead, does not exist, is putrefying or has lost his/her blood or internal organs. Rarely, it can include delusions of immortality."

4)Synecdoche was conceived as Charlie Kaufman's first "horror" film. True to form, he follows through to the letter, creating a work of art that reflects the true meaning of the word. What is horrible about Caden Cotard's life and condition? Well, check that definition of Cotard's first, but aside from that, consider his connection to reality: he slowly loses track of time. Years pass, but he mistakes it for weeks. We witness the nagging dilution of a man's identity throughout his life, and his desperate attempts to create something artistic that signifies what it's like to live, until he succumbs to observing his life, without living it.

***OK, back again. It's a pretty depressing movie, really. And to boot, the story flounders in the middle as the complications increase, and we lose interest in the characters as our grasp on what's happening slips away. But that shouldn't discourage you from seeing it, if, in any capacity, you're fascinated by anything that we've said. Oh yeah, and it's funny too, even if we often found the audience was laughing in parts we read as dead serious.

The complications exists because nothing in modern realist dramas is "real," to Charlie Kaufman. It's not real because the brain is infinitely more complicated than a linear drama—he's not sure why the brain's reality doesn't play a larger part: dreams, voices in your head, distorted senses of self and others, metaphor as reality. Synecdoche tries to change the landscape of modern studio films in a serious way.

What we really wanted was to enjoy and be prodded by this foolishly complicated meditation on life, perspective, identity, and the creative process, with the eerie suspense of the film's first 40 minutes. When the movie completely shifts tones halfway through, we regret that change a little, because the first bit is so good, and so creepy, we wished it lasted for the next two hours. Ultimately, the overall effect is a little wonderful, and will provide a full evening's chatterbox at the coffee shop. Isn't that what going to the movies should be about?

Check out ex-Austinist, now international media mogul/hand model, Matthew Odam's excellent interview with Kaufman here, yoga details included.

Email This Entry


Comments (4) [rss]

user-pic

Wow. Surprisingly good film write-up for the Austinist. Or anywhere else for that matter.

Thanks for the compliment, Benj.

Man, it's been two weeks since I've seen this movie, and I still can't stop thinking about it!

That's interesting about Cotard's Syndrome. I did not pick up on that being his last name.

Man, I need to see this again...

Yeah, Nubc4kes, a bunch of us have had that feeling :) There should be a Synecdoche support group.

I missed the Cotard's syndrome at first, I think the NYTimes review dropped the hint for me. It's pretty hilarious how closely the Wiki definition follows the movie (or the other way around).

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

About Austinist

Austinist is a news and culture website about Austin, Texas. We publish Monday through Friday, and also maintain a guide to local arts and entertainment events that we call the Weekly IST List.

Editor: Allen Y Chen
Publisher: Gothamist

Recent Comments

Dig It

Contribute

Latest Tip:

where's the public outcry over the condition of waterloo park?
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Austinist.

All Our RSS