“Don’t believe the hype,” Public Enemy warned us way back in 1988, and as on their eerily prescient “Cold Lampin’ With Flavor” which made the surprising case for Flava Flave’s longevity, they were right, of course. And hype, by definition, should always be suspect. From the moment Vampire Weekend, the quirky New York quartet began making the blog rounds and collecting the sort of adjectives that pointed their way toward them becoming The Next Big Thing, we, as a music community, needed to take a breath, sit down, and just relax. Losing our shit about inventive New York rock debuts are just going to result in another band like The Strokes, and we all know where that got us.
A study in contrasts: four years ago, a band called Extra Golden recorded an album in Nairobi, featuring Africans Otieno Jagwasi and Inyango Wuod Omari, as well as Alex Minoff (of Weird War) and Ian Eagleson. While the album had its Western halves in indie rocker Minoff and the multi-faceted Eagleson, the album favored more traditional African song structures mapped out by Jagwasi and Omari and was not, as Eagleson said, “like Paul Simon’s Graceland." The resulting album OK-Oyot System was put out by Thrill Jockey in 2006, but its unfamiliar stylings may have put it at odds with the listening public. Vampire Weekend, however, is band made up of four attendees of Columbia University and zero Africans, and their album sounds, in part, to have been directly influenced by Graceland in general, and by “Crazy Love Vol. II” in particular. Extra Golden are a cult favorite, and Vampire Weekend a sensation who have played Letterman. Go figure.
As an album, Vampire Weekend’s self-titled LP is an inventive record notably different from those of their peers – namely thanks to their afrobeat bent – but which also falls in line with most of what you might expect from the indie rock records foisted on us in the past six months or so, with all their positives and negatives intact. While it’s not your everyday album, all that talk about this band’s African-based ingenuity – at a fever pitch, at this point, and partially propelled by the band themselves – is overblown. Good songs buoyed by a very real but also truncated interest in the music of Africa is one way to sum up the music on Vampire Weekend. The four dudes in Vampire Weekend may be fans of afrobeat, but their songs recall the deft indie stylings of Islands and The Shins and, like Beirut, an attention to old forms given a facelift for an audience who like older music but really love scattered-pop mercenaries like Neutral Milk Hotel, or the long winded Decembrists, or '70s stalwarts The Talking Heads, for instance.
The songs soar with quick-stepping snare drums and wandering synths, and “A-Punk” delightfully spins post-punk into the equation. “Cape Cod Kwassa Kwassa” holds traditional African music closer to the vest, with auxiliary percussion and skipping guitar leading the way. At other points, Vampire Weekend seem less “Upper West Side Soweto,” as they like to describe themselves, and more just jumpy rockers with a good ear for melody. Either way, it’s different, but not too different, and that seems to be enough for some. Depending on what you’re looking for, Vampire Weekend might very well have your number. But if you’re expecting this Next Big Thing band to usher in something other than a good but not great debut, then you’re going to be disappointed. And what is hype if not a prelude to disappointment?

SXSW 2010: Austinist's List Of Day Shows, Afterparties, and More



Good review.
Also: Ivy schoolers should never be allowed to describe themselves as "Upper west side Soweto" without being hit in the face with a shovel.
Well worded review. But if hype is the fear why comment at all?
As much as indie reviews sneer and snarl the vast majority just follow a little mini-corporate spin model with all their name checked brethren and chummy party goers. If pitchfork reviews you can bet that brooklyn vegan has, and most likely the austinist too.
don't believe the hype? how about, don't partake in the hype.
lester bangs the jersey beat.
good review...but eh..i prefer beirut over vw any day of the week..except for maybe thursdays.
somehow i missed the hype before i heard the record (or maybe it happened after i heard it) either way: untainted, it's a great record